Monday, October 15, 2012

Sci fi vs fantasy

I think that, as a society, we read "fantasy" books so much more often than "science fiction" books because of the rate in which our society makes scientific discoveries.  In order for science fiction to be "fiction" it has to outstrip what is currently scientifically possible.  In order to have these new science fiction premises understood by readers they have to be explained at least somewhat.  With how complex science is becoming there aren't that many people who want to sit there and try to understand these new concepts.  Fantasy, and magic, are a little bit easier to read because a lot of fantasy worlds draw from the same concepts, and its completely normal for the understanding of magic, which is a fairly common theme in fantasy, to evolve throughout the story.  This is especially true because magic itself doesn't have to "be explained" in the conventional sense.  It is allowed to work simply because thats what it does, and this makes it easier for people to read.  The reader comes to understand the concepts as the story progresses, rather than having to learn all about what you will need to know about whatever technology is in the story before the story starts.

Fantasy books also seem to be both longer, and more in depth as well.  Fantasy series, at least in my experience, have more books in their series. I have seen series with 10+ books, yet the longest scifi book I have ever seen is 8 books, which were actually technically 2 separate 4 book series that take place over the same time but from different perspectives.

Great science fiction books tend to be somewhat confusing.  Neuromancer, by William Gibson, is an extremely confusing book.  Its won many awards, but its still confusing to read.  Something that would be a modern version of Neuromancer(Award wise), but in the fantasy field, would be something like Harry Potter.  On an understanding level Neuromancer is significantly more difficult to understand.  Many people will read, and have read, Harry Potter because it's both interesting and easy.  Many fewer read Neuromancer because it is interesting, but also requires significant thought to understand.

(I edited this post for clarity)

2 comments:

  1. You make an interesting point by addressing the length of fantasy novels compared to science fiction. Perhaps it's an indication of their lasting appeal to a range of audience members that they can span novel after novel? I also agree that science fiction can require a higher level of comprehension than science fiction, and perhaps that turns people off to the genre.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree with Angie, the point about the length of the books is very interesting. Now that I think about it, the books I've read are longer and more detailed and I think that's why I found them so interesting. They vividly describe the scene so you can picture it. I don't read much science fiction but I have read some and they were only one book but the author wrote a lot of books. Those books were interesting but they did require a little bit of knowledge about the concepts to completely grasp. Very interesting post!

    ReplyDelete